Call us (347) 256-2195

My Account
International Women's Day Special

10% Off All Women's Jewelry Find the Perfect Gift at Benny's Bling NYC

Best Sellers

View All
FANCY BRACELET 14KW FG VS CVD DIA 18CTS

FANCY BRACELET 14KW FG VS CVD DIA 18CTS

$4,558.54
PRINCESS CROSS PENDANT 14KW EF VS1 HPHT DIA 2.07CTS

PRINCESS CROSS PENDANT 14KW EF VS1 HPHT DIA 2.07CTS

$1,053.36
(1.19CT) IGI PRINCESS ENGAGEMENT RING 14KW PINK VS2 CVD DIA 2.09CTS

(1.19CT) IGI PRINCESS ENGAGEMENT RING 14KW PINK VS2 CVD DIA 2.09CTS

$2,120.36
OVAL ETERNITY RING 14KW EF VS1 HPHT DIA 3.53 CTS

OVAL ETERNITY RING 14KW EF VS1 HPHT DIA 3.53 CTS

$1,220.80
OVAL ETERNITY RING 14KW EF VS1 HPHT DIA 3.49 CTS

OVAL ETERNITY RING 14KW EF VS1 HPHT DIA 3.49 CTS

$1,213.10
(0.66CT) IGI HEART HALO PENDANT 14KW/Y FG VS2 CVD DIA 0.27GRM

(0.66CT) IGI HEART HALO PENDANT 14KW/Y FG VS2 CVD DIA 0.27GRM

$897.46
CUBAN BRACELET 14KW FG VS2 CVD DIA 5.57CTS

CUBAN BRACELET 14KW FG VS2 CVD DIA 5.57CTS

$7,932.95
BASKET STUD EARRING 14KW DE VS2 HPHT DIA 1.17CTS

BASKET STUD EARRING 14KW DE VS2 HPHT DIA 1.17CTS

$246.27
BASKET STUD EARRINGS 14KW DE VS2 HPHT DIA 1.18CTS

BASKET STUD EARRINGS 14KW DE VS2 HPHT DIA 1.18CTS

$247.21
FANCY SOLITAIRE RING 14KR PINK VS2 CVD DIA 2.94CTS

FANCY SOLITAIRE RING 14KR PINK VS2 CVD DIA 2.94CTS

$1,637.09
(3.27CT) IGI HEART FANCY SOLITAIRE RING 14KY PINK VVS2 CVD DIA 3.27CTS

(3.27CT) IGI HEART FANCY SOLITAIRE RING 14KY PINK VVS2 CVD DIA 3.27CTS

$2,217.74
TENNIS BRACELET 14KW FG VS CVD DIA 8.45CTS

TENNIS BRACELET 14KW FG VS CVD DIA 8.45CTS

$2,752.18
TENNIS BRACELET 14KW EF VS1 HPHT DIA 11.29CTS

TENNIS BRACELET 14KW EF VS1 HPHT DIA 11.29CTS

$3,193.40
Luxury Jewelry, Reimagined

Lasting Sophistication in Every Detail

Fine Jewelry Redefined

Timeless Elegance in Every Piece

Men's Jewelry

Gold Chains

Pendants

Rings

Earrings

Women's Jewelry

Necklaces

Bracelet

Pendants

Earrings

SHOP WITH CONFIDENCE

Everything you need to know before purchasing is right here, from fit and delivery to authenticity and long term care. If you would like personal support, our team is ready to help. Reach out by phone or chat and a Benny’s Bling NYC specialist will guide you every step of the way.

Orders are typically processed within 1–3 business days after payment is confirmed. Standard U.S. shipping is free and usually arrives within 5–7 business days. Expedited shipping takes about 2–3 business days, and overnight shipping is available upon request for an additional cost. Yes, we also offer free in-store pickup at checkout, and most pickup orders are ready within 1–2 business days unless the item is custom-made.
Returns and exchanges can be requested within 30 days of delivery for eligible items in new, unworn condition with original packaging, certificates, and documentation included. Custom, personalized, engraved, altered, clearance, and final sale items are generally non-returnable unless defective. Approved refunds are issued to the original payment method within 7–10 business days after the item is received and inspected. Customers are usually responsible for return shipping unless the item was defective or incorrect.

Yes — one complimentary resize within [60 days] on most designs. Eternity bands, tension settings, and certain styles may not be resizable. Typical turnaround is [3–7 business days]. After the complimentary window, a [resizing fee] applies.

Customer Reviews

From the first consultation to the final pickup, the process felt effortless. I was able to choose every detail and the ring turned out even better than I imagined. The craftsmanship is incredible and the fit was spot on.

Verified Customer

Daniel P., Queens

We designed an oval lab-grown engagement ring and benny guided us through every detail—setting height, band width, and certification. The result is stunning, and the complimentary resize made the fit perfect. Couldn’t be happier.

Verified Customer

Melissa R., Brooklyn

The team walked me through stone options, proportions, and timing without ever rushing me. The final result looks stunning in person and feels very high quality.

Verified Customer

Anthony M., Staten Island

I was nervous ordering a custom piece, but the communication made everything easy. Seeing the design come to life was an amazing experience. I would absolutely do this again.

Verified Customer

Natalie K., Brooklyn

WHY BENNY’S BLING NYC

Benny’s Bling NYC was created to redefine how modern fine jewelry is experienced. We combine skilled craftsmanship with honest guidance and a deep respect for the meaning behind every piece. From carefully sourced materials to detailed bench work, quality and intention guide everything we create.

Whether you are buying or selling, you can expect privacy, clarity, and straightforward communication. Our specialists evaluate each piece using professional grading standards and current market insight to ensure fair pricing. Every visit is designed to feel effortless, with flexible options including purchase, trade, consignment, or upgrade, along with secure handling and fully insured delivery.

Your Cart

Your cart is empty